Wednesday, April 1, 2020

Maps of Meaning - Table of Contents

An Analysis of Jordan B. Peterson's Maps of Meaning

1. Maps of Meaning: The Why and Who of Jordan B. Peterson
He had a voice inside that couldn't go with the lefty rubbish

2. Maps of Meaning: What Failure to Respond to Chaos Means
It means becoming a lefty victim

3. In Media Res: Peterson and Stark
Chaos, morality, social control

4. Ancient Myth and My Three Peoples Theory
Can Three Peoples be meshed with Great Mother, Great Father, and the Son?

5. But First, Humans are Tribal
The capitalist/libertarian world view is not enough, because humans are tribal 

6. The Alt-Right Takes Out After Jordan Peterson
Peterson isn't defending the Christian culture and the nation state

7. Jordan B. Peterson's "Maps of Meaning:" It's a Start
Can we emerge from our need for safety to the challenge of the Sacrificial Hero?

8. The Two Paths: Rich Kids After the Death of God
Either the nostalgia of "activism" or the real path of self-discovery

9. Why I Think Jordan Peterson is Important
He is saying what I am saying, only better.

Deirdre McCloskey - Table of Contents

Deirdre McCloskey and her Bourgeois Era books
  1. McCloskey Week: Conservatism's Big Problem
    We need a discrediting of the One Big Thing ethos

  2. McCloskey Week: Bourgeois Dignity
    About 300 years ago we started to respect the bourgeoisie

  3. McCloskey Week: The Moral Case Against Obamanomics
    The right of people to order their lives without permission from the government

  4. McCloskey Week: It's Not What You Think
    We have to look with tolerance on the projects of the mad projectors

  5. McCloskey Week: The Messenger
    Maybe the shameless transsexual McCloskey is just what we need

  6. McCloskey Wrapup: Big Fact vs. Big Mistake
    Fact: prosperity has increased 30 times. Mistake: we need to control distribution 

  7. McCloskey Again: 787 Pages for What?
    A rehash of Bourgeois Virtues and Bourgeois Dignity

  8. McCloskey Again: Why Not Call the Book "Bourgeois Rhetoric?"
    Apparently both left and right opposed "trade-tested betterment" 

  9. McCloskey Again: The Bourgeoisie is Not That Interested in Power
    Because today, life is not a matter of life and death. Everything is negotiable

  10. "Why Liberalism Works" for the Gentry
    But not necessarily for Commoners and Clients

  11. Could Chile's Collapse Happen Here?
    It could, except we Commoners have Donald Trump in our lane

  12. It's Past Time for Merely Defending the Market System. Etc.
    Why not go on the attack

Great Reaction in Brief

The old world, before capitalism, was feudal, a system of domination and subordination, from the king and his direct vassals down to the meanest serf on a lord's estate.

Then came the 19th century with ordinary people running all over the world without permission, inventing new things and selling them. All over the world. And it worked! Trade and cooperation could work on the basis of trust between nobodies, with the legal system as a backstop to take care of cheaters.

It was in the middle of the 19th century that rich kids invented socialism proposing to reestablish the old regime of top-down control. Rich kids would save the workers from a fate worse than death by beating up on the employers and capitalists. After World War I another generation of rich kids extended the notion to include other marginalized groups as approved victims.

I call this movement the Great Reaction, a nostalgic lurch to the imagined Garden of Eden of a vanished past, a reassertion, if you like, of primitive archetypes that dwell in the human collective unconscious.

I say that:

Socialism is a return to slavery
The welfare state is a return to feudalism
Identity politics is neo-tribalism
Reparations is neo-vengeance
Activism a return to revolution, rioting for the ruling class, part medieval knight-errantry, and part activisme, or gentry kids putting on a school play for their parents
Helpless victims are a return to sacrifice
Social justice is good old loot and plunder

And I say that there is no greater task for humans than meeting and answering the challenge of the Great Reaction, the deeply instinctive turn away from the disruptive change of the modern era and its Great Enrichment and back to the primitive.

Great Reaction Table of Contents

Little Darlings in Brief

Ruling classes have their supporters, and according to the rule of politics they must supply them with loot and plunder for their valuable services to the regime.

But in our age we have not just the active supporters of the ruling class but the helpless victims on whose behalf the ruling class acts. It was Karl Marx that invented this political concept by founding the Communist Party of educated youth who would fight for the proletarians against the bourgeoisie.

I call these clients of the ruling class "Little Darlings."

But I have come to regard this notion as similar to the rich guy and his mistress, his Little Darling that he showers with gifts and jewelry. Until she grows a little too old, or starts to act up. Then our Sugar Daddy drops her, poor thing, for a newer model.

And she thought he really loved her.

That is what has happened to the white working class in the United States and elsewhere. There was a time when the progressive ruling class lived and died to help the working class. But no longer. Today the progressive ruling class is making love to women and minorities.

Today we speak of the white working class "dying of despair," although I suspect that discarded mistresses have lived forever on their rage.

But I wonder when the progressive ruling class will grow tired of women and minorities in their turn?

Not yet: that we know.

Little Darlings Table of Contents

Charles Murray - Table of Contents

Charles Murray and his books

By the People: Rebuilding Liberty Without Permission

  1. By The People: Part I: Where We Stand

  2. By the People: Part II: Opening a New Front

  3. By the People: Part III: A Propitious Moment

  4. Summing Up "By the People": We Want More

Coming Apart: The State of White America, 1960-2010

  1. Coming Apart: The Setup

  2. Coming Apart: the New Upper Class

  3. Coming Apart: The New Lower Class

  4. Coming Apart: Why It Matters

Facing Reality

  1. Murray Facing Reality: The Setup

  2. Murray Facing Reality: the Outcome

  3. Murray Facing Reality, Yes You Liberals

Commentary

  1. The Underclass: Remember Them?

  2. New Party Leader Addresses Brit "Broken Society"

  3. Let's Make a Deal on Immigration

  4. Just Don't Say the M-Word

  5. Democrats' New War on Poverty

  6. MoveOn dot Next?

  7. Conservatism Brain-Dead?

  8. America's Class Divide

  9. Duck and Cover, Mr. President

  10. Romney's "Gaffes"

  11. Is the Future Cognitive?

  12. America's Verdict on Obama

  13. Misunderstanding Charles Murray

  14. The Democrats' Educated Voter Problem

  15. Liberals Out of Touch

  16. Marriage: It's For the Next Generation

  17. America's Moral Challenge

  18. The Next Great Moral Movement

  19. Obama's Great White Whale

  20. Poor Having Fewer Babies

  21. Merry Christmas, Suckers

  22. Three Liberal Injustices

  23. How Obama Guys Worry About Inequality

  24. Inequality: Good Cop, Bad Cop

  25. Liberals on the Wrong Side of Main Stream of Life

  26. Liberal Fingerprints All Over It

  27. The Top 20% Just Wants to be Free

  28. The Real Inequality Problem

  29. What are Police For?

  30. Put Not Your Trust in Princes

  31. A Letter to Charles Murray

  32. How Liberals Wrecked Upward Mobility

  33. Liberal Robert Putnam Still Doesn't Get It

  34. The Obama Implosion Alert.

  35. Working Class Angst: The False God of Politics

  36. Shoulda Woulda Coulda Avoided Trump

  37. Sorry, Charles Murray, You Don't Get It

  38. What Do You Mean by "Hate" and "Xenophobia" Liberals?

  39. Yes, What Should Democrats Do Now?

  40. We are not in Conservative Kansas Any More

  41. Middlebury is Feckless, According to Murray

  42. The Damore Case: What Do Liberals Want

  43. What Fools These Liberals Be

  44. Politics is Downstream from Culture is Downstream from Religion

  45. Two Economies: Remember Charles Murray

  46. What Do We Know About Sex in the Lower Classes?

  47. The Left's Power of Silence

  48. Global Problem #1: Birthing a Religion for the Educated

  49. The Worm in the Apple of all Administrative Institutions

  50. Understanding Tlaib: The Culture of Innocence

  51. The Left's Dilemma: It Can't Undo Its Mistakes

  52. Suppose Blacks are Now Becoming "Commoners"

  53. Applying Yarvin's Gentry, Commoners, Clients to Charles Murray's "Coming Apart"

  54. Deficits: Where Does It End?

  55. Another Three Layer Theory: From Joel Kotkin

  56. Dying of Despair: What Should We Do About Cultural Decline?

  57. Contra Harari: Analyzing "Sapiens" on Empire

  58. Ten Reasons Why Our Liberal Ruling Class is in Trouble

  59. Charles Murray's Last Broadside "Facing Reality"

  60. A Hollow Elite: The Roots of Wokeism

Perfect Plan in Brief

If you ask me, we have two problems in our modern world. The first problem is the hard road traveled in our age by the migrants from country to city, the transformation in culture needed in rural, agricultural people come if they are to thrive in the city. The second problem is the culture war being conducted against ordinary middle-class commoners by the educated ruling class.

I have a two part Perfect Plan to solve this two part problem.

Part One of my Perfect Plan helps the migrants from country to city learn, first, how to cope with their new life in the city, and then learn to wive and thrive in the city culture and economy with the best of them and become city people.

How do we do that? Teach people the culture of The Road to the Middle Class, which means religion, education, mutual aid, and living under law. Wow. I wrote a book about that.

There is a lot to learn about how to become a bourgeois, a city person. You need to learn to trust other people; you need to learn how to serve your fellow humans with a useful skill and keep updating it; you need to learn to accept the verdict of the market with a good will. Above all you need to live and let live.

Part Two of my Perfect Plan is to institute a culture of tolerance among the People of the Creative Self, the artists and writers and activists that presently rule the the culture of  the world. Right now, artists and writers and activists are carefully taught that there is nothing worse than the responsible culture of the bourgeoisie unless it is the racist sexist homophobic culture of the white working class. 

The reason that our friends the People of the Creative Self need to learn tolerance is quite simple. Most of the commoners, the responsible city people in the world are not ready to become creative. Moreover, as in many things, many are called to be creative, but few are chosen. 

In the old days, the creative class felt themselves to be an embattled minority that had to defend each others' backs; but now the creative class has switched from defense to offense. Today the People of the Creative Self can swarm around anyone they don't like and get them fired from their job. They have the power, in other words, to dominate the public square.

This power, I suggest, is a Bad Thing, and unless we curb it -- as all power should be curbed -- with a new culture of tolerance among our creative and educated elite.

Perfect Plan Table of Contents

Nietzsche - Table of Contents

Reactions to Nietzsche

1. Jordan B. Peterson's "Maps of Meaning." It's a Start
Can we emerge from our need for safety to the challenge of the Sacrificial Hero?

2. The Problem with Politics
It never knows when to stop

3. Peterson and Jung and Nietzsche, Oh My!
Can the three peoples make sense of modern psychology?

4. My Critique of the Left. Again
A history of activism since 1848

5. On Darwin and Escape Hatches and the Will to Power
You need to figure out what to do when things go wrong

6. The Two Paths: For Rich Kids after the Death of God
Either the nostalgia of "activism" or the real path of self-discovery

7. Tribalism: The Empty Middle
Between Progressive Activists and Devoted Conservatives

8. Not Left vs. Right, but Skeptic vs. Fanatic
The whole point of limited government is to put the leash on the fanatics

9. Nietzsche Railed Against "The Priests", but Now "The Priests" are Wealthy Liberals
And we need to rail about wealthy liberal "priests"

10. The Problem of Creative People and Power
Too many people want to get the creative rush from political power.

11. Now the Lawyers Want to Do Diversity and Inclusion
Are you lawyers racists and sexists, or what

12. Free Spirit vs. Fettered Spirit
Updating Nietzsche's notion for the 21st century

13. Nietzsche on the Criminal Law
Disgrace for he that can feel shame, punishment for the rest

14. Bronze Age Mindset Gets the Michael Anton Treatment
BAP wants to be a pirate. Is that good or bad?

15. Let's Check Out the Woman Question
Maybe women will end up returning to wiving and thriving

16. My Journey from Common Sense to Common Sense
Yes, my common sense understands why lefties are going crazy

17. Suppose Lefty Activists are Just Faking It, Like Actors
Activism is a form of acting. Like the ancient Greeks

18. Nietzsche in 900 Words, If You Can Take It
Morality, decadence, nihilims, eternal recurrence, übermensch

19. Being Thankful Towards the End of Life
Since everything is "accidents and nonsense" stop complaining!

20. Nietzsche on Knowledge and Reality
There are no facts, only interpretations

21. The Question of Whether the Deep State is Clever or Stupid
They just assume that conventional wisdom and things-as-they-are explain the world

22. "Why Liberalism Works" for the Gentry
But not necessarily for Commoners and Clients

23. Roger Scruton, RIP
A remarkable man, gentle, learned, courageous

24. The Intersection of "Groundhog Day" and Nietzsche
Decadence, nihilism, eternal recurrence. It's all there

25. The German Turn: How Germans Invented the Modern World
Everything from relativity to modern pyschology

26. Suffering, Religion, History and the Three Peoples
The different ways in which different people experience suffering

27. What Path Should We Follow?
It depends on what kind of person you are