Over the last year or so I have been developing the idea that the people that govern us are idiots. I mean by that merely that, after the establishment of a dynasty -- which requires at the very least ruthlessness, and probably genius combined with that gift of the gods, luck -- the sons and adepts of the founders are not so bright. Hey, they don't have to be.
This is not that hard. It stands to reason, for instance, that the American Founders had to be extraordinary men. Start with Washington, the military leader that kept the Revolutionary army in the field for six long years in strategic retreat until the opportunity came to defeat the fever-ridden Brits and their allies at the Battle of Yorktown. Then Madison, the man that wrote most of the Constitution. Hamilton, the guy that helped persuade New York to vote for the Constitution and then founded the US National Debt.
The point is that if these men were not extraordinary then we wouldn't be here today as the last best hope of man on Earth.
But after the founding generation, the need for genius and perseverance eases off. And the great offices of state get to be occupied by men of lesser quality. There is nothing wrong with that, it is just the way the world works. But when the need for great men appears again, then "cometh the hour, cometh the man." We hope.
Only, of course, the men that can't rise to the occasion must first be flushed away, as McClellan was flushed away in favor of Grant.
Now at last I am reading Holman W. Jenkins, Jr. say in the Wall Street Journal that all these deep state actors are idiots. In "Clapper Disinformation Campaign" Jenkins proposes that the Deep State actors we have grown to know and love in their ongoing series "Trump Collusion" -- now in Season 2 on Netflix, or is it Amazon Prime? -- are really not that bright.
Jenkins looks back at the Intelligence Community's actions in 2016: Comey's intervention in the Hillary emails, surveilling low-level Trump nobodies, the reopening of the Clinton email business in the last week of the campaign.
What is clear is that the Brennans and the Clappers and the Comeys and the rest of them are pretty good at playing bureaucratic pinochle with leaks and smears and tame journalists. Only that sort of thing is, or should be, beneath the dignity of major bureaucratic nabobs.
It is a conceit of mine that I can tell the good men from the fakes. Bill Clinton: a truly brilliant politician. Hillary Clinton: a prisoner of conventional wisdom and her female rage. Barack Obama: a weak man that compensated by cutting corners. Trump: a man who plays an idiot on TV.
Likewise, I have really tried in conversation to tune my antennas to determine whether my opposite is just reciting conventional wisdom that anyone would possess from a college education and exposure to mainstream media, or whether he has actually formulated an original idea.
To me, everything we know about Trump Russia and the counter-intelligence spying on the Trump campaign reeks of mediocrity: dull mediocre place-servers allowing themselves to be sucked into folly and political malpractice, mostly because they were too weak to tell their superiors to go take a hike. Everything about the Deep Staters reeked of weakness: getting old war-horse Stefan Halper to try and compromise low-level Trump hangers-on; queering the pitch of the Hillary private server investigation.
Back in the day Archibald Cox refused to compromise the Department of Justice to please the Nixon people. Not any more, not in today's Department of Justice and today's Federal Bureau of Investigation.
The only thing to hope for is the God still looks after drunks, children and the good old US of A, and will help us replace the current weak and feeble Deep Staters with men of firmer mettle.
On the other hand, it is really fortunate that the Obama crowd were such weak and feeble yes-men, and didn't really abuse their powers too much. Otherwise they could have really done some damage to the nation.
This is not that hard. It stands to reason, for instance, that the American Founders had to be extraordinary men. Start with Washington, the military leader that kept the Revolutionary army in the field for six long years in strategic retreat until the opportunity came to defeat the fever-ridden Brits and their allies at the Battle of Yorktown. Then Madison, the man that wrote most of the Constitution. Hamilton, the guy that helped persuade New York to vote for the Constitution and then founded the US National Debt.
The point is that if these men were not extraordinary then we wouldn't be here today as the last best hope of man on Earth.
But after the founding generation, the need for genius and perseverance eases off. And the great offices of state get to be occupied by men of lesser quality. There is nothing wrong with that, it is just the way the world works. But when the need for great men appears again, then "cometh the hour, cometh the man." We hope.
Only, of course, the men that can't rise to the occasion must first be flushed away, as McClellan was flushed away in favor of Grant.
Now at last I am reading Holman W. Jenkins, Jr. say in the Wall Street Journal that all these deep state actors are idiots. In "Clapper Disinformation Campaign" Jenkins proposes that the Deep State actors we have grown to know and love in their ongoing series "Trump Collusion" -- now in Season 2 on Netflix, or is it Amazon Prime? -- are really not that bright.
Jenkins looks back at the Intelligence Community's actions in 2016: Comey's intervention in the Hillary emails, surveilling low-level Trump nobodies, the reopening of the Clinton email business in the last week of the campaign.
There is a term for how this all looks in retrospect: colossally stupid.Yeah, really. What in the world did the FBI think it was doing? And the Brennans and the Clappers too? Getting into the middle of an election? Trying to compromise low-level campaign hangers-on? Faking up applications to the FISA Court? What man of weight would get into that kind of shenanigans? Your really big men would regard it as below their dignity to play penny-ante political poker.
What is clear is that the Brennans and the Clappers and the Comeys and the rest of them are pretty good at playing bureaucratic pinochle with leaks and smears and tame journalists. Only that sort of thing is, or should be, beneath the dignity of major bureaucratic nabobs.
It is a conceit of mine that I can tell the good men from the fakes. Bill Clinton: a truly brilliant politician. Hillary Clinton: a prisoner of conventional wisdom and her female rage. Barack Obama: a weak man that compensated by cutting corners. Trump: a man who plays an idiot on TV.
Likewise, I have really tried in conversation to tune my antennas to determine whether my opposite is just reciting conventional wisdom that anyone would possess from a college education and exposure to mainstream media, or whether he has actually formulated an original idea.
To me, everything we know about Trump Russia and the counter-intelligence spying on the Trump campaign reeks of mediocrity: dull mediocre place-servers allowing themselves to be sucked into folly and political malpractice, mostly because they were too weak to tell their superiors to go take a hike. Everything about the Deep Staters reeked of weakness: getting old war-horse Stefan Halper to try and compromise low-level Trump hangers-on; queering the pitch of the Hillary private server investigation.
Back in the day Archibald Cox refused to compromise the Department of Justice to please the Nixon people. Not any more, not in today's Department of Justice and today's Federal Bureau of Investigation.
The only thing to hope for is the God still looks after drunks, children and the good old US of A, and will help us replace the current weak and feeble Deep Staters with men of firmer mettle.
On the other hand, it is really fortunate that the Obama crowd were such weak and feeble yes-men, and didn't really abuse their powers too much. Otherwise they could have really done some damage to the nation.